One of the most powerful parts of this chapter for me was
Dr. Perry’s initial interpretations of Virginia, Laura’s mother. I was so
impressed with how he honored Virginia and her undeniably important role in
Laura’s life and recovery. The stark contrast between the two pages that
described the various invasive medical procedures performed on Laura, her
doctors’ resistance to searching for any psychological explanations for her poor
health, and her overwhelming medical history and the single sentence that
portrayed Perry’s approach to Laura’s case—reading the intake report and
deciding to simply introduce himself to Laura and her mother—left a smile on my
face. While he was clearly interested in Laura’s medical history, he did not
burden himself with a preliminary analysis of the ins and outs of the seemingly
endless hospital records and chose instead to focus on Laura and her mother as
humans deserving of a compassionate introduction. This set him apart from every
other medical professional Laura and Virginia had interacted with and laid the
foundation for an empowering therapeutic alliance.
I considered our readings from the week of the 20th
on engaging parents as partners in the therapeutic process (Cates, Packman,
Paone, & Margolis, 2006; Kottman, 2003). Instead of actively including (or
even making basic attempts to engage) Virginia in her daughter’s treatment, the
various professionals that worked with Laura pathologized Virginia as an
inadequate mother, ignored her, and even discouraged her from interacting with
her daughter. Simple attempts to demonstrate basic compassion, engage Virginia
as an expert on her life, or identify her strengths as a mother early on may
have put both her and her daughter on a completely different and smoother path
to recovery. Perry demonstrated these essential skills from his first
interactions with Virginia and Laura and went above and beyond to understand
Virginia’s background and tailor treatment to her unique needs.
This is the first chapter in which Perry extensively
highlighted the importance of caregivers in a traumatized child’s development
and journey to healing. His focus on helping Virginia process through her own
experiences of childhood trauma and neglect and learn to facilitate nurturing,
loving interactions between herself and her daughter resonated with me. I
thought about the parents who want nothing more than to provide their children
with a different childhood experience than the one they had growing up and are
dead set on not repeating the patterns of maladaptive caregiving behavior,
abuse, or neglect that they experienced at the hands of their own caregivers.
While this is an admirable perspective and many parents are able to raise their
children differently than they were raised, the past often remains stored in
the deepest, most unconscious parts of our psyche. Logically deciding to be a
different kind of parent is simply not enough, which was illustrated clearly
and empathically in this chapter with Virginia. Reading about Perry’s referral
of Virginia and Laura to Mama P was a deeply emotional experience: this
treatment approach was restorative for both Laura and her mother, who needed
the same nurturing, curative love and care that her daughter did.
Hi Carly,
ReplyDeleteI am glad you pointed out that the various professionals working with Laura focused more on pathologizing Virginia than bringing her into the therapeutic process. I think this tendency to blame parents for their children’s illness dates back to early theories on mental illness. Many people used to believe that mental illnesses, especially schizophrenia, were the result of “bad parenting”. Even though we know family isn’t to blame for mental illness, practitioners are still inclined to fault caregivers. I have to admit to being guilty at times for blaming parents for a child’s problems. After hearing how a parent treats a child or witnessing it first hand, I’ve had the thought more than once, “no wonder this child is like this”. The more I’ve learned, the more I’ve realized this thought comes more from my own frustration.
The medical professionals treatment of Virginia was hard to swallow because she wasn’t event being one of the stereotypical “difficult” parents. From what I understood, she was doing everything to help her child and everyone appeared to be pushing her away. As you said, parents often want nothing more than to provide their child with a different childhood experience than the one they had, but it’s not that easy. Fortunately, Perry understood what Virginia and Laura needed.
I agree that reading about Virginia and Laura’s experience with Mama P. was deeply emotional. I can’t even begin to imagine the healing Virginia and Laura experienced. I’m curious if that type of referral happens often now; my instinct says no. This chapter really reflects the deep importance of involving parents in the therapeutic process with a strengths-based approach.